Easter break office closure 

We will be closed from 5pm Thursday 17 April 2025 until 10am Tuesday 22 April 2025. You can still submit your complaint via our online form but we will not respond until we reopen.

New Customer Service Standards

We have updated our Customer Service Standards and are looking for feedback from customers. Please fill out our survey here by 12 May 2025: https://forms.office.com/e/ZDpjibqe8r 

Investigation Report 200603138 200603250

  • Report no:
    200603138 200603250
  • Date:
    April 2008
  • Body:
    Lothian NHS Board and A Medical Practice, Lothian NHS Board
  • Sector:
    Health

Overview

The complainant (Mrs C) complained that both her mother (Mrs A)'s GP Practice (the Practice) and Templar Day Hospital (Hospital 1) failed to examine Mrs A thoroughly enough to correctly diagnose her broken hip.  She felt that Mrs A suffered unnecessary pain and limited mobility due to incomplete examinations and assumptions being made by staff of both bodies.

Specific complaints and conclusions

The complaints which have been investigated are that:

  • (a) the Practice misdiagnosed Mrs A's broken hip as arthritis (not upheld);
  • (b) the Practice failed to follow correct procedures to consider any problems other than arthritis (not upheld); and
  • (c) Hospital 1 staff failed to diagnose Mrs A's broken hip prior to, or during, months of physiotherapy (upheld).

Redress and recommendations

The Ombudsman recommends that Lothian NHS Board (the Board) review Hospital 1's admissions procedures to ensure that all patients receive a full diagnostic assessment prior to the commencement of treatment.

The Board have accepted the recommendations and will act on them accordingly.

Updated: December 11, 2018